Archive for the ‘Introducing’ Category

Islam – Sunni and Shia

The Succession to Muhammad

As one might imagine, the death of the Prophet threw the Muslim community into chaos. Some refused to believe it was true; others wondered what would happen now that he was dead. It was clear that he was the last in the chain of the Prophets and so whoever succeeded him would not be another Prophet. However, just as Muhammad had been the spiritual, legal, political and military leader of the community, so all four responsibilities were to rest upon the shoulders of his successors.

Sunni

It is no surprise to us that sometimes the events of history are told differently by different groups. The group that became the majority amongst Muslims is called the Sunnis, who make up about 85% of Muslims today all over the world. Sunnis believe that neither the Qur’an nor Muhammad said who was to succeed him nor did he lay down a procedure for selecting his successor.

For the Sunnis, as long as the leader ruled under God, following the guidance of the Qur’an and Sunna, it was a role that could be filled by any man, based on his piety and wisdom. Leadership was to be by merit; not by inheritance, birth or family.

Accordingly, a group of the leading figures in Madina selected Abu Bakr (d. 634), as the first Head of the Community after Muhammad. He had been one of Muhammad’s closest companions and one of the earliest converts to Islam. In the last few days of his life, when he was very weak and ill, the Prophet asked Abu Bakr to lead the prayers. Indeed on one occasion Muhammad joined the congregation and prayed behind Abu Bakr. This is seen by the Sunnis as indicative that he was approved for collective leadership after Muhammad’s death. Abu Bakr was presented to the believers and accepted by a majority. He only lived a further two years. He appointed Umar as his successor.

Umar was accepted by a majority of believers and served as Caliph for ten years (634-644). Towards the end of his life, Umar nominated six prominent Companions who were to elect his successor from amongst themselves. They chose Uthman as the third Caliph (644-656). He was followed by Ali (d.661), the son-in-law and cousin of Muhammad, who was elected by the community. The leadership of the first four Caliphs was accepted by most of the community. They are called the Rightly-Guided Caliphs, the Rashidun. The period of their leadership (632-661) is considered as a golden age, in contrast to the dynasties of rulers who came after them. These later Caliphs took up a more secular lifestyle and the Caliphate became the preserve of certain clans or families.

Shi’a

A minority group among Muslims had a different approach to Muhammad’s succession. Their name comes from the fact that they supported Ali’s right to succeed the Prophet. Hence they became the Party of Ali, or Shi’a-t Ali, which is shortened to Shi’a.

According to them, the Qur’an refers to the succession to the Prophet in Q. 5:55. This verse was revealed relating to an incident in which Ali gave away his ring in charity. Another verse speaks of the Family of the Prophet, the Ahl al-Bayt, being made pure and spotless [Q. 33:33, 3:61]. This is held to be a reference to an incident in which Muhammad, his daughter Fatima and son-in-law Ali, and their two sons Hasan and Husayn, were all purified by God, making them the highest of creation.

Further evidence in support of the Shi’a view of divine selection is provided by an incident which happened on the return journey from the Hajj shortly before Muhammad died. Muhammad called a halt at an oasis, where he raised the hand of Ali and said publicly that whoever held him as their leader should regard Ali in a similar way.

This is taken by the Shi’a to be the appointment by Muhammad of Ali as his successor. The three men who were later to be acclaimed as the first three Rightly-Guided Caliphs, were present at this time and all then pledged allegiance to Ali.

Immediately after the death of Muhammad, Ali was engaged in the preparations for the burial of the Prophet’s body. The group of Companions met and selected Abu Bakr to head the community. When Ali found out what had happened, he didn’t protest. He felt it would be unworthy to claim the leadership. He did, however, make his position clear. Umar and later Uthman succeeded Abu Bakr. Then in 656, after the death of Uthman, Ali assumed the Caliphate.

In Shi’a terminology, the divinely appointed leaders of the community in succession to Muhammad are called Imams. To the Shi’a, Imam Ali was the first divinely appointed successor and the first three Rightly-Guided Caliphs had no right to this position.

The close relationship between Muhammad and Ali provides the Shi’a with a clear model of what an Imam should be. The Qur’an refers to Ali as Muhammad’s nafs, which can be translated as something like ‘soul or inner self’ [Q. 3:61]. So Ali was seen as having the same inner light as Muhammad. In other words, he inherited from him the light of divine guidance.

This is why the Shi’a regard the divinely appointed Imams as infallible in interpreting the Qur’an and the Islamic way of life. They receive divine inspiration or ilham rather than direct revelation from God in the way that Muhammad did. This confers on them the supreme authority and knowledge to interpret the Shari’a in ways binding on the believers. The Imams were also sinless, possessing both spiritual and political authority.

All Imams come from the Family of the Prophet, as descendants of Fatima and Ali. Each Imam appointed his successor on the basis of piety and wisdom according to the guidance of God. This did not necessarily mean the eldest son, as in a monarchical system. The selected one is God’s choice as inspired guide and is entitled to political authority, even if rejected by the community.

The line of Imams descended from Ali, through his two sons, Hasan and Husayn, until the twelfth Imam in succession disappeared from sight in 874; and then into the Greater Occultation in 941, in which he is beyond contact with all human beings, where he will remain until the beginning of the Last Days. There was a dispute about the rightful fifth Imam, which resulted in the formation of the Zaydis. Subsequently, there was another dispute about the rightful seventh Imam, which resulted in the Isma’ilis, amongst whom are the Bohras and the Nizari Isma’ilis, amongst the latter the largest group are the followers of the Aga Khan.

The first Imam, Ali, was declared such by Muhammad. Then each Imam in turn infallibly declared his successor. Each Imam is “the Proof of God”, the guardian of the correct meaning of the Qur’an and Sunna. They draw from the Light of Muhammad, so cannot go wrong, nor can they exceed or deviate from the truth that he knew and passed on to them. The Shi’a believe that the earth is never without the presence of an Imam, because otherwise the true meaning of faith would be lost. The Hidden Imam is both the Imam of the Present Age and the Awaited One, Imam al-Mahdi, who will one day return to establish true faith and justice throughout the earth.

Because of the centralised authority of the Imams, the Shi’a claim an additional 300 years of infallible guidance. It was these Imams who guaranteed the deposit of the Hadith of Muhammad according to the Shi’a collections.

The Shi’a have always been a minority, often living alongside and intermingled with their Sunni brothers and sisters. It is common for Sunni and Shi’a to marry one another and the day-to-day living out of their faith is very similar.

During our own time, the time of the Hidden Imam, the Islamic guidance of the community rests in the hands of a body of Shi’a scholars. Amongst these are the Ayatollahs, who are recognised as the most learned and pious. The most highly respected of these Ayatollahs are acknowledged experts in Shari’a and so ordinary Shi’a Muslims today take the rulings of these select Grand Ayatollahs as authoritative guidance on the way in which they should live their lives.

Since the 16th Century, with the founding of the Safavid dynasty (1501-1765), Shi’a Islam has been the recognised religion of Iran, and Shi’a are a majority in Iraq and Bahrain. They are also significant minorities in Lebanon, Syria, Saudi Arabia, Pakistan, India and some Gulf States, as well as in other Arab countries.

By Dr Christopher Hewer, St Ethelburga’s Fellow in Christian-Muslim Relations

The World through Christian Eyes

A description of Christian belief

Christianity

“We believe in one God : Father, Son and Holy Spirit”

God the Father
God is known to Christians as the Creator and Father of all. The Bible emphasises the goodness of God and that everything he made was in the beginning good. Human beings have a special place in God’s creation. We are created to enjoy friendship with God – as one famous 4th century African Christian, Augustine of Hippo, put it, “You have made us for Yourself and our hearts are restless until they find their rest in You.” Humans are also described as being made “in the image of God”, and one very important element in this is the idea that men and women have a shared stewardship of creation, accountable to God for its use and care. The first commandment in the Bible is to love God and the second is to love our neighbour. Genuine love is a choice, so God created human beings with the ability to make choices, and we acknowledge that we do not always make the right ones. Thus in the creation story at the start of the Bible while God gives the first people everything they need and asks them to show their love and trust towards him, they choose to disobey. This disorders their relationship with God, with each other, and with the rest of creation, making them and the created order, susceptible to pain, sickness, and death.

God the Son

God’s desire is to forgive and to restore all in life that has been damaged and corrupted, and the first part of the Christian Bible, the Old Testament, tells the story of God’s faithful love for his people.

God promises Abraham that through him all the families on earth will be blessed. In the history of Israel the people see for themselves God’s power to rescue when he frees them from slavery in Egypt and from exile in Babylon. They receive laws including the Ten Commandments, which express God’s will and way for human life. God also reveals his character and purpose through prophets. An expectation grows of a great “day of the Lord” in which evil will be defeated and the good rule of God will be established on earth. Some believed this would involve a special ruler known in Hebrew as the Messiah (in Greek ‘the Christ’). Christians believe that all these hopes were fulfilled in Jesus of Nazareth.

The life of Jesus is mentioned by ancient historians but described in more detail in the four books called Gospels which begin the second part of the Christian Bible, the New Testament. Jesus was born in Bethlehem: Christians celebrate this at Christmas and believe that in this event God took flesh and became one of us. Jesus taught almost exclusively among his fellow Jews. His central message was that “the kingdom of God has come,” declaring that the hope of the reign of God had begun to be fulfilled. Jesus showed what this was like by healing the sick, casting out demons, declaring sinners forgiven, welcoming outcasts and challenging the rich and powerful. He claimed that in all this he was fulfilling the Scriptures. Opposition to him led to his arrest, trial and death by crucifixion, but Christians believe that on the third day after his death and burial Christ was raised bodily from the dead. They believe that through this, his radical path of uncompromising love amid misunderstanding and rejection was vindicated. By his death and resurrection, life overcomes death, good defeats evil, and human beings are able to have their relationship with God fully restored. It is the events of Jesus’ death and resurrection that Christians celebrate at Easter.

God the Holy Spirit

Jesus’ disciples acclaimed him as the Messiah and the Son of God. They began the work of calling all people to receive God’s forgiveness and the gift of a new life by turning from sin and putting their faith and trust in Jesus Christ. With the coming of the Holy Spirit at the festival of Pentecost the first Christians experienced the presence of God and the abiding power of the risen Christ in a personal way. Through the Spirit this experience is promised to all Christians.

Pentecost is therefore regarded as the birthday of the Christian Church, the community of those who belong to Jesus Christ. Christians seek to model their lives on Jesus’ teaching and example of generosity, purity, justice and forgiveness. Thus the purpose of Christian life, within the community of the Church, is to live and share Christ’s self-giving love. In the Lord’s Prayer Jesus taught his followers to pray to God as Father, seeking his help and living in daily relationship with him. By the power of the Holy Spirit and through the guidance of the Church, Christians seek to discern God’s ways and to work thereby for the fulfilment of God’s kingdom of justice and peace. They believe this will not be completed until Christ returns as judge to renew all of creation. As Christians proclaim, “Christ has died, Christ is risen, Christ will come again.”

One God for all the World

So Christians believe in one God.

Without ever ceasing to be the Creator and Father of all, God became a human being, Jesus Christ, God the Son, in order fully to reveal his love and to undo the consequences of our disobedience.

Without ever ceasing to be the Father and the Son, this one God gives himself as God the Holy Spirit to all who put their faith in him, and is active in all the world.

The one God, revealed as Father, Son and Holy Spirit, offers himself to all people to work with him to rescue, renew and restore all of his creation.

By

London Diocese Willesden Area Apologetics Group

The Revd Fergus Capie

The Revd Laurence Hillel

The Revd Simon Reed

The Revd Preb John Root

The Revd Felicity Scroggie

An Introduction to Buddhism

Buddhism, as we know it today, began in North East India with the life of Siddhartha Gautama, the historical Buddha, who lived, scholars believe, in the fifth century BCE (some traditional datings cite the sixth century BCE). After the Buddha’s death, the Buddha’s teaching spread throughout north India and into what is now Pakistan and Central Asia. In the third century BCE, through the missionary work of the Mauryan King, Asoka, it spread south to Sri Lanka and possibly to what is now Shan State in Myanmar. From Sri Lanka, it spread to other parts of Myanmar, Thailand, Cambodia and Indonesia. By the first century CE, it was also travelling along the Silk Road towards China. In the fourth century C.E. it reached Korea and in the sixth century, Japan. In the seventh century C.E. it crossed the Himalayas into Tibet. Buddhism eventually disappeared from India, although the twentieth century saw its return through immigration from Tibet and the conversion of low and ’scheduled caste’ Indians through the example of the politician, Dr Bhimrao Ambedkar (1891-1956). A further half million, including many in the UK, converted on the fiftieth anniversary of Dr Ambedkar’s death.

Today, there are two main divisions within Buddhism worldwide:

  1. Southern Buddhism, usually called Theravada Buddhism (The Way of the Elders), which is found in Cambodia, Laos, Myanmar, Sri Lanka, South Vietnam and Thailand. In addition, Nepal, although not a traditionally Theravada Buddhist country, has seen a Buddhist revival through the work of Theravada missionary monks. Theravada Buddhists are united through monastic discipline and lineage, and their canon of texts, in Pali.
  2. Mahayana Buddhism (The Great Vehicle), which is found in Bhutan, China, Japan, Korea, Sikkim, Tibet, North Vietnam and many parts of central Asia before the rise of Islam. Mahayana Buddhism can be further divided into East Asian Buddhism and Tibetan Buddhism, which, in its tantric form, is sometimes called Vajrayana (The Diamond Vehicle). Mahayana texts are extensive and are usually used now in their Tibetan and Chinese translations.

As Buddhism travelled from India, it did not demonise the religiosity it found but sought supremacy through incorporating local practices and beliefs into Buddhism. As long as the Buddha was placed above them, gods, spirits and celestial beings could enter the Buddhist pantheon. Then, in China, Buddhism met Taoism, which resulted in a creative interpenetration between the two systems of thought at a philosophical level. The result of this is that within schools of Buddhism and even within one country, there is variety. For instance, in Japan, there is a division between Zen and Pure Land Buddhism, the former emphasizing ‘own power’ – reaching a point where enlightenment is possible through one’s own effort, the latter stressing ‘the other power’ of Amida Buddha. In addition, Japanese Buddhism contains movements that try to fuse the two, and also modern lay movements such as Rissho Kosei Kai and Soko Gakkai.

All forms of Buddhism are present in the West, together with new Buddhist movements such as the Friends of the Western Buddhist Order, which has sought to create a form of Buddhism appropriate for the West.

Buddhism: a view and a way

Textbooks on Buddhism usually state that the Four Noble Truths are the core of Buddhism. Not all Buddhists worldwide, though, would mention the Noble Truths first if asked about their religion. Yet, across all schools and countries, they might mention what are called the three jewels: the Buddha (the historical Buddha and also, especially for Mahayana Buddhists, countless other Buddhas), the Dharma (the Truth about the cosmos that the Buddhas teach, which includes the Four Noble Truths) and the Sangha (the monastic community or the community of dedicated followers of the Dharma). If one can go to these three precious things for refuge and strength, one is a Buddhist.

The Buddha

The historical Buddha, according to the traditional biography, was born into a comfortable, aristocratic or royal home and was protected from suffering. He married Yasodara and had a son, Rahula. At age of 29, after encountering suffering for the first time, he left home and family to become a searcher after spiritual truth. After rejecting two spiritual teachers and the path of asceticism, he gained enlightenment at 35 years of age and spent the next 45 years teaching and building up Orders of celibate monks and nuns. He died at the age of 80 of food poisoning. The scholar may go little further than this, seeing the Buddha as a remarkable spiritual leader who enjoyed a long life and had considerable influence on the religious history of India. Through the eyes of faith, however, the historical Buddha was more than a human teacher. He was an enlightened being who had prepared for his final life as Buddha through countless previous lives, mastering 10 perfections. In the Theravada tradition these are generosity, morality, renunciation, patience, truthfulness, determination, loving-kindness, energy, equanimity, wisdom. The Mahayana tradition usually speaks of 6 but these were also expanded to 10: generosity, morality, patience, courage, meditation, intuitive insight, skilful means, vow, power and knowledge. So, as one who had mastered these perfections and awoken to liberating Truth, the Buddha was, ‘a wonderful man’, ‘a teacher of gods and humans’,’a knower of worlds’. He was the embodiment of what he taught – compassion and wisdom, the two poles of enlightenment in Buddhism.Theravada Buddhists use the following salutation:

Such, indeed is the blessed One: Exalted, Omniscient, Endowed with knowledge and virtue, Auspicious, Knower of Worlds, A Guide incomparable for the training of individuals; Teacher of gods and humans, Enlightened and Holy.

Most importantly, he was one of many Buddhas, all of whom taught the same message. Theravada Buddhists believe that each era produces one Buddha to teach humankind. The Mahayana tradition goes far beyond this. Buddhas are as numerous as the sands on the river Ganges and can exist simultaneously. The historical Buddha was an embodiment of the cosmic reality of Buddhahood. Each person because of innate buddha nature can become a Buddha.

The Buddha image is a focal point for intense devotion, which includes prostration, chanting and the offering of flowers, light and incense. It is a devotion that involves the body and the mind. What the Buddha taught is remembered with thankfulness. But more than this, as devotees position themselves in front of the image, they imagine the Buddha’s compassion and wisdom and, for some, these qualities come alive, flowing from the image, bathing them in light. They also believe that the very act of devotion will bring good consequences and blessings. When flowers are offered, the following words are chanted in Pali, by Theravada Buddhists:

With diverse flowers the Buddha I adore, and through this merit may there be liberation. Even as these flowers must fade, so does my body reach a state of destruction.

The Dharma

The Dharma (Pali dhamma) literally means that which ’supports and upholds’ the universe. It is the way things are. It is the truth about the cosmos. It is what all Buddhas become awakened to.

The overriding problem for Siddhatha Gautama and all Buddhas was suffering or the unsatisfactoriness that lies at the heart of existence. Why are we born only to grow old and die? Why are we separated from those we love? Why are we placed with those we do not like? Buddhists believe the Truth the Buddhas saw at their enlightenment pinpointed the problem and offered the solution; that it gave a view of the world and a path towards liberation.

The Four Noble Truths are the ‘house’ within which this view and path are usually placed. The first Truth is the Truth of Dukkha or pain/unsatisfactoriness. It affirms that something is twisted and out of shape at the heart of existence. Dukkha is one of three characteristics of existence. The other two are impermanence and non-self. Taken together, these three characteristics assert that everything in samsara, the word in Pali and Sanskrit for the cycle of repeated birth and death that individuals undergo until they attain nirvana, is impermanent, including the self, and that the experience of this makes life appear unsatisfactory.

The Second Noble Truth, the Truth of Arising, declares that the root cause of life appearing unsatisfactory and full of pain is craving – seen traditionally as craving for pleasurable experiences, for continued existence and even for non-existence. In other words, in a world characterised by impermanence, dukkha arises when an individual craves for and clings to that which cannot last, whether this is youth, beauty, possessions, status, relationships or human existence itself, in ignorance of its true nature. In an extension of this Truth, the causes of our pain and dis-ease are often pictured in Buddhism as greed, hatred and ignorance (or delusion) – greed for what is pleasant, aversion towards what is unpleasant and ignorance of the three characteristics of existence.

Taken together the two Truths encapsulate the first step in Buddhism’s view of the world. That the world is enmeshed in selfish craving and that we are bound to be reborn again and again in the several planes of existence, which include hells, heavens, the animal realm and human existence, because of our craving is repeated again and again in Buddhist literature. It is a view that is linked with the Law of Karma. Karma (Pali: kamma) literally means action. So the Law of Karma is the Law of Action. And the Law of Action in Buddhism asserts that each action has a fruit. Wholesome actions will bear wholesome fruit. Unwholesome actions will bear unwholesome fruit. So, if a human life is characterized by acts motivated by selfish craving then that human will experience painful consequences during life and will, at death, gain a painful rebirth.

The principle behind the Law of Karma is that of cause and effect, and it is this that informs the next step in Buddhism’s view of the world and the Third Noble Truth, the Truth of Cessation. This asserts that there is a way out of suffering because the world is governed by cause and effect. So, if the cause of dukkha is eradicated, dukkhais eradicated. If craving – and the greed, hatred and ignorance connected with it – are eradicated, suffering/pain/unsatisfactoriness cannot arise. The message of the Third Truth is that we need not be tied to the round of rebirth. We can be liberated.

The Fourth Noble Truth is the Path to the Cessation of Dukkha, an Eightfold Path: right thought; right speech; right action; right livelihood; right effort; right mindfulness; right concentration. At its heart is advice about plucking out the poisons of greed, hatred and delusion. It is sometimes reduced to a threefold formulation: morality, meditation and wisdom.

This teaching results in a spirituality that places more emphasis on what one does than on what one believes. Faith that the Buddha’s teaching is true is most important but it is not enough by itself.

The goal of the Buddhist path, according to traditional doctrine, is nirvana or nibbana in Pali. Nirvana arises when greed, hatred and delusion or ignorance have been eradicated from the heart and mind. The texts are economical about what they say of nirvana. In some senses, it is beyond our vocabularies. What can be said is that it is liberation from the prison of self and liberation from rebirth. As such, it is highest ethical good, the highest bliss, the highest happiness, the highest truth. It is where absolute wisdom and compassion meet. Mahayana Buddhists picture it as the realisation of our Buddha Nature. Some Buddhists assert that it is attainable in this life; others, probably the majority in Asia, will say that it is far in the future – a better rebirth is all that can be worked for in the present.

The Dharma in Practice

In the Theravada tradition, verse 183 of a popular text, the Dhammapada has, in recent history, been used to sum up the Buddhist path: ‘Not to do evil, to cultivate good, to purify the mind – this is the teaching of the Buddhas’.

Generosity, the ability to give what one has to others, and virtuous conduct form the bedrock of the Dharma in practice in all Buddhist traditions. They are the first step in drawing the mind and heart away from greed and hatred. Virtuous conduct is defined by what Buddhists call the Five Precepts. These go back to the beginnings of Buddhism and are more or less common to all schools. They are voluntarily undertaken commitments not to kill or injure living beings, not to take what is not given, to avoid misconduct in the sensual sphere, not to be involved in false speech and not to take intoxicants that cloud the mind.

To complement the Five Precepts, which concern refraining from certain kinds of action, positive qualities are also developed, again with the ultimate goal of drawing the mind away from greed and hatred. Giving has already been mentioned. Important also are four qualities that are often linked with meditation, but which spill over into conduct: loving kindness; compassion; sympathetic joy (being able to take joy in the success of another even though one is not experiencing success oneself); equanimity (being able to think and act without being torn between greed and hatred). An ancient discourse, the discourse on loving kindness has these words at its heart: ‘Just as a mother would protect her child at the risk of her own life, so cultivate a boundless heart (of loving kindness) to all beings’. This includes surrounding your enemies or those you do not like with loving kindness.

The quality of compassion is important in all forms of Buddhism but was taken to new heights in the Mahayana tradition with its stress that all living beings can become Buddhas, in other words can be filled with the compassion and wisdom of a Buddha. For some Mahayana Buddhists this involves taking what is known as the Bodhisattva Vow (the vow of a Buddha-to-be) – that they will not enter nirvana (and so leave the realm of rebirth) until all beings have been liberated. This may mean voluntarily being reborn numerous times over to help others.

For the lay person, seeking teachers who have spiritual authority is also important. In some Tibetan schools, finding a teacher who can transmit the teachings of the Buddha and staying with this teacher is central to Buddhist practice.

The last practice mentioned in the Dhammapada verse 183 was, ‘to purify the mind’. This is done through meditation or what Buddhists call bhavana (lit: cultivation or becoming). Buddhist meditation is a form of mental culture that is personally transforming. It seeks to deal with the problem of dukkha by working on the mind and heart, where greed, hatred and delusion take hold. There are many forms of meditation in Buddhism but most come under two headings: tranquillity or calming meditation (samatha); insight meditation (Skt. vipaayana; Pali: vipassana).

The aim of samatha practice is to gain one-pointedness of the mind through concentrating on a meditation object such as the breath. This can lead to what Buddhists call the dhyanas(Pali jhanas) – meditative absorptions that are successively more refined, moving from bliss, to equanimity, to states where normal perception is transcended. Vipassana meditation aims at direct appreciation of the truth of the Buddha’s teachings, such as the three characteristics of existence: impermanence; unsatisfactoriness and non-self. One form of insight meditation is ‘bare attention’ or mindfulness and involves watching what is happening in the body and the mind in the present moment. This can lead both to insight into the truth of impermanence and also to seeing more clearly how one’s mind works, for instance how it veers between attraction and aversion.

In the 20th Century, the term ‘Engaged Buddhism’ was coined to denote a form of Buddhism that was specifically directed at analysing the political and social causes of suffering in the world and eradicating them through social action. Some Buddhists believe that the term is not necessary, since all forms of Buddhism seek to help others and are therefore engaged. Those who use the term, however, insist that it is a necessary counterbalance to the individualism that is sometimes linked with Buddhism.

The Sangha

The literal meaning of the term is assembly or congregation. In many Asian Buddhist communities, it refers to the Orders of monks (Skt. Bhiksu; Pali bhikkhu) and nuns (Skt. Bhiksun?; Pali bhikkhun? ), who are seen as the representatives of the Buddha on earth and as a group of people who are progressing faster along the Buddhist path because they have left behind the attachments to home and family that lay people are bound to. In traditional Buddhist contexts, there is a mutually dependent relationship between lay people and monastics. Lay people provide monks and nuns with food, clothing and other needs; the monastics provide lay people with teaching and with ‘a field of merit’, in other words with the opportunity to perform actions (e.g. the giving of food and robes) that will bear good fruit. Both monks and nuns follow strict rules of discipline, the Vinaya, which go back to the time of the Buddha.

In other contexts, particularly among western Buddhists, the Sangha is seen as the whole community of Buddhists – all who are walking along the Buddhist path. The importance of spiritual friendship is stressed.

In addition, a distinction is made in both Asia and the West between the Sangha and the Arya-sangha or Noble community – those Buddhists, lay or ordained, who have attained one of four or five spiritual levels that place them on the supramundane path leading to nirvana. Doctrinally speaking it is the Arya-sangha in which Buddhists should take refuge.

Buddhism in Britain

The 2001 census showed that there were 151,816 Buddhists in Britain. The majority of these are Asian, from countries such as Burma, China, Japan, Sri Lanka, Thailand and Vietnam. There are also sizeable numbers of western converts.

The history of Buddhism in Britain, generally speaking, begins in the nineteenth century when missionaries, civil servants and travellers to the British possessions of Sri Lanka and Myanmar collected and translated Buddhist texts, wrote about what Buddhists believed and brought their impressions back to Britain. Some Buddhist students also came to study at British Universities. Missionary accounts of Buddhism usually presented the religion in a negative light. Other writings were more positive, including Edwin Arnold’s 1879 poem, The Light of Asia, which presented the Buddha as a hero who gave up his affluence and family out of compassion for the world.

By the 1870s, members of free-thought movements antagonistic to Christianity and of what we might call today New Religious Movements, such as theosophy (founded in 1875), were being attracted to Buddhism because they believed it to be unencumbered by the problems associated with Christianity. It was non-theistic and rational. The first British western converts come from these groups, for example Allan Bennett, who became a Buddhist monk in 1901 in Myanmar and led the first Buddhist mission to Britain in 1908 as Venerable Ananda Metteyya. The Buddhist Society of Great Britain and Ireland was formed the previous November, partly in order to greet him. The Buddhist Society, based in London, serving all schools of Buddhism, is its successor.

The next important mission from Asia was led by Sri Lankan revivalist, the Anagarika Dharmapala, who founded the Maha Bodhi Society in 1891 and spoke at the Parliament of the World’s Religions in Chicago in 1893. This resulted in the first Buddhist monastic community in Britain – 3 Sri Lankan monks settling near Regents Park in 1927. There are now several monastic communities in Britain serving Sri Lankan Buddhists ( and some western converts). In addition, there are centres serving Thai (from 1964), Vietnamese, Burmese and other Asian Buddhist communities.

‘Theravada Buddhism’

It was with Theravada Buddhism that the first British converts to Buddhism had contact, because of Britain’s imperial links with Sri Lanka and Myanmar. Attempts to establish a monastic centre in Britain for western converts to Theravada Buddhism did not succeed until the 1970s, when the English Sangha Trust (founded in the 1956) invited two Thai teachers to help them. One of them, Ajahn Chah, brought with him an American, Ajahn Sumedho, who founded the Chithurst Forest Monastery. This led to further centres being founded, most significantly, the Amaravati Buddhist Monasterynear Hemel Hempstead in 1985.

Numerous meditation groups now exist in Britain linked with Theravada practice sometimes known as

Zen Buddhism

Zen was the next form of Buddhism to influence Britain. There are two main forms of Zen – Rinzai and Soto. Both can be found in Britain together with Korean, Vietnamese and Chinese forms. D. T. Suzuki (1870-1966) was key in bringing Zen to the West. One of the key figures within the later Buddhist Society, Christmas Humphreys, was influenced by him. In 1972, Throssel Hole Priory, a Zen centre, was established in Hexham – it still exists. There are numerous Zen centres and groups in Britain, including groups linked to the Vietnamese Zen master, Thich Nhat Nanh.

Tibetan Buddhism

After Zen, came Tibetan Buddhism. One result of the Llasa Uprising against Chinese intervention in Tibet in 1959 and the flight of the Dalai Lama in to exile was that Tibetan Buddhist teachers came to the West. In 1988, the largest Tibetan centre in Europe was opened on the borders of Scotland, founded by two Tibetan teachers, Chogyam Trungpa and Akong Rinpoche – the Kagyu Samye Ling Monastery and Tibetan Centre. Britain is now home to different Tibetan schools and groups.

Pure Land Buddhist Organisations

Shin Buddhism is the Pure Land School that is best represented in Britain. In 1976, the Shin Buddhist Association of Great Britain as founded and in 1977, the Pure Land Buddhist Fellowship. A significant ‘Engaged’ Pure Land Centre, founded by western converts to Buddhism, is the Amida Trust, based in Narborough.

Other Japanese Buddhist Groups

Two twentieth century lay Japanese Buddhist movements also work in Britain: Soka Gakkai (The Value Creation Society, now known as Soka Gakkai International, founded in 1930) and Rissho Kosei Kai (Society for Righteousness and Friendship). In addition there is the Nipponzan Myohoji Order, which focuses on peace issues and has established two peace pagodas in Britain, one in Milton Keynes and one in Battersea Park.

Western Buddhist Groups that do not trace their lineage to one Asian tradition

The largest western group of this kind is the Friends of the Western Buddhist Order (FWBO), founded by Sangharakshita (Dennis Lingwood) in 1967. The Western Buddhist Order was founded in the following year. It aimed to draw the best from all schools of Asian Buddhism to create a Buddhism relevant and attractive to westerners. FWBO centres are found throughout Britain.

Resources

Useful Books

R. Bluck, 2006, British Buddhism: Teaching, Practice and Development, Abingdon: Routledge

Heinz Bechert & Richard Gombrich (Eds.), 1984 (pbk 1990), The World of Buddhism, London: Thames and Hudson.

Elizabeth J Harris, 1998, What Buddhists Believe, Oxford: Oneworld (a book that grew out of a radio series on Buddhism that Elizabeth wrote and presented for the BBC World Service)

Peter Harvey, 1990, An Introduction to Buddhism, Cambridge University Press (a book that has been re-printed almost every year since 1990)

Ramona Kauth & Elizabeth Harris (Eds.), 2004, Meeting Buddhists, Leicester: Christians Aware (£12.20) This can be ordered from Christians Aware, 2 Saxby Street, Leicester LE2 0ND; www.christiansaware.co.uk

Damien Keown, 2005, Buddhism: A Very Short Introduction, Oxford University Press,

Aloysius Pieris, 1988, Love Meets Wisdom: A Christian Experience of Buddhism, Maryknoll, New York: Orbis Books

Perry Schmidt-Leukel (Ed), 2005, Buddhism and Christianity in Dialogue: The Gerald Weisfeld Lectures 2004, London, SCM.

Useful Websites

Society for Buddhist-Christian Studies:

European Network for Buddhist-Christian Studies:

The Buddhist Society (London):

Amaravati

www.buddhism.about.com

www.buddhanet.net

www.bbc.co.uk/religion/religions/buddhism

An insight into Hinduism

Hinduism is the name given to the religion that originated in India. The word Hindu came about as a mispronunciation of the name of an ancient river in India called ‘Sindhu’. Hinduism is often misunderstood to be a polytheist religion. (I.e. believing in many almighty Gods and Goddesses). This is not true. Hinduism is in fact a ‘pluralistic’ religion that suggests that God (or Spirit) can be perceived and approached in a variety of ways. This teaching is central to Hinduism. It emphasises that as we are all different, the way we will think of and approach the ultimate reality (God or spirit) will necessarily be different.

Basic beliefs:

Dharma (from Sanskrit root dhar – which means to uphold)

The name given to religious pursuits is called Dharma. The word can mean ‘righteous living’; sometimes it is compared to the ‘cohesive force that holds society and civilisation together’. The deeper meaning of the word Dharma is to ’search for the innermost nature of everything both ‘external and internal’.

Founders: (Rishis from Sanksrit root ‘Drish’ meaning one who sees)

Hinduism claims many founders. They are called ‘Rishis’. The word ‘Rishi’ literally means one who has seen God. Hinduism claims that the message of spirituality is refreshed in all times and in different countries again and again by seers called ‘Rishis.’

Scriptures:(Two categories: Shruti – with authority & Smriti with less authority)

There is a vast range of scriptures. Some, like the Veda ~ Upanishads, relate the spiritual experiences of the Rishis and are considered to have a higher authority. Some, like the mythological stories, are called the Puranas and are considered to be secondary. The Bhagavad Gita is considered by most Hindus to be the most authoritative scripture in their religion. This text is a spiritual dialogue given by Krishna and explains the philosophy of Hinduism and how it can be made practical and adopted in daily life.

Law of Karma and Reincarnation

These are central tenets of Hinduism. The law of Karma is the law of action and its consequences on personal terms. The idea of reincarnation is also central to all Indian religions, including Buddhism, Sikhism, Jainism. There is interesting research done on the theory of reincarnation at the University of Virginia by Professor Ian Stevenson. Please check the website to explore these ideas. Also view the book Called Childrens Past life Experiences – details at: http://www.childpastlives.org/

Concept of God: (Pluralism – many pathways and hence many religions but still pointing to the same God)

Hinduism being a pluralistic religion offers a vast variety of concepts of God.

Broadly these can be divided into two categories. (Take note: Hinduism does not say that any one approach is better than another is. The choice depends on the individual or any religious group).

God as a personality (sometimes with form and sometimes without form)

Hinduism suggests that as we are human one of the ways we can relate to the idea of God is to think of Him or Her as having a personality. Just like any personality He must have a character. For God, all religions, including Hinduism, like to give him qualities of truth, goodness, compassion, power, knowledge. The two main movements within Hinduism for those who like to think of God in this fashion are called the Arya Samaj and the Brahamo Samaj. One of the offshoots of Hinduism, Sikhism also likes to think of God as a personality but without giving Him any form. But many Hindus do not stop at thinking that God can be thought of as a personality. They are quite happy to think of Him with form. The form chosen is not the form of God but the form the devotee likes to use to think of God. This is a major difference with the Abrahamic faiths that do not like to give form to God. Note: when Hindus worship images of God (do not make the mistake of calling them idols as that is considered to be a demeaning word) the images are called Murtis. They are not worshipping stone or marble that the images are made from. They are worshipping the being that is represented by those images.

Concept of God as a principle that underpins everything (Brahman/Atman):

This approach to God is unusual. It says that the inner being we call our ’self’ is a manifestation of God. The same God is shining in the eyes of every living thing. Like lots of little puddles reflecting the same infinite sky. The essential nature of all living things is really God. When we help anyone we are helping God (or ourselves only). Hence reverence for all living things springs naturally from Hinduism. The definition of God as being our true self is called ‘Atman’. The self becomes manifested as ‘consciousness’. Consciousness defies all classifications. Hence this concept of God is called God beyond the form and the formless. One of the greetings used by Hindus is ‘Namaste’. This gesture literally means ‘reverence to God as your true self’.

How can both be true?

Hinduism accepts both these approaches to God:

(a) As a personality and as a

(b) Formless principle.

How can both be true? The reconciliation is offered using the following metaphor.

Hindus claim that like ‘ice and water’ the same entity can be a personality with form and a formless principle – without form. It is the love of the devotee that freezes the formless God into the form of his or her desire. Hence there are many images of Gods and Goddesses in Hinduism. All these are various approaches adopted by Hindus to reach out to God. They represent tried and tested pathways to God. Therefore all these forms are revered. This is why you find so many different images of God.

Science and Religion

One of the greatest problems world religions face is the challenge from science and rationality. The Hindu contribution on the relationship between Science and Religion: -

The teachings of Hinduism suggest that all disciplined human endeavours including science will eventually lead to conclusions that are in line with the findings of spirituality. This seems to be coming true in the Science of today.

Diet

Many Hindus who come from Gujarat or from Tamil-Nadu may be vegetarian. This means that they do not eat meat, fish or eggs. However cakes or biscuits containing eggs are considered acceptable by most of these people. Nowadays quite a few Hindu families residing in the UK (including some families from Gujarat and Tamil Nadu) have adopted meat-eating habits. The only meat they will not consume is beef as the cow is considered to be the most sacred animal.

Sectarian movements

Hinduism is represented in the UK by many Sectarian bodies. There is a great difference in the way they perceive and approach God. This can be a cause for confusion. One of the main sectarian bodies in the UK are the Swaminarayan movement. This group believes in God with form and quality (as Lord Narayan or Vishnu). The majority of Hindus in the UK prefer to think of God with form and qualities; however there are some Hindu groups that like to think of God without form but with attributes like ‘Truth’ or even as our essential nature called ‘Atman’. The fact that Hinduism allows and encourages a variety of approaches to God means that all these sectarian bodies co-exist within Hinduism and are all considered to represent valid Hindu pathways to God.

Worship / Prayer

Hinduism teaches that it is the heartfelt love for God that counts more than any strict formal codes that may be adopted in any ritualistic practice. Hence the rules of worship or prayers can vary a great deal from family to family. The prayer that all Hindus consider to be central is called the ‘Gayatri’. The Gayatri translates as: “Let us meditate on the glorious effulgence of that Supreme Being who has created the universe; may She enlighten our hearts and direct our understanding.”

Yoga

The word yoga is often associated with postures and physical exercises. However it has a more esoteric meaning. It means ‘Pathway of communing with God through meditation’. Practising short periods of silence or contemplation is a good way to start the process.

Contemporary Spiritual Personalities

This is another extraordinary feature of Hinduism. Hinduism suggests that as spirituality is an empirical subject, the proponents of spirituality cannot be restricted to ancient times. It puts forward the idea that just as prophets of the past experienced God and offered spiritual teachings to mankind, prophets continue to be born in all ages and in all nations. They continue to refresh the message of spirituality. Many Hindu families will show affinity to some such contemporary figure. It is very tricky to decide which of these personalities to promote. It is left to the individual to decide for him or herself.

Philosophy:

Hindu philosophy is very ancient and is in agreement with the findings of modern sciences such as: Quantum Mechanics, Neuroscience, Cosmology and Evolution. These philosophies are also in agreement with the philosophic reasoning that God can neither be proved nor disproved through mental gymnastics, else He becomes a subset of our mental apparatus and loses his potency. God has to remain crucially invisible hence Hindus support the stand of a humble agnostic ~ God can neither be proved nor disproved.

Major misconceptions about Hinduism

(1) Hinduism is not a polytheist religion. It is a pluralistic religion suggesting many pathways to the same God. This allows many religions to co-exist with dignity and without having to score points over each other.

(2) Hindus do not worship ‘objects or idols’. The images are tools used to focus on an infinite God. Every religion does it but some do it knowingly while others do it unknowingly.

(3) Hindus do not worship the cow. They revere it as the best candidate in the animal kingdom to receive the thanks of mankind.

Teachings of Hinduism that can be relevant to our times

(1) ‘The Sanctity of life’. This principle of non-violence, called Ahimsa, is central in Hindu teachings. It teaches respect for living things extending into the animal and plant kingdoms. This teaching comes naturally from the philosophy of Hinduism.

(2) Yoga practised experimenting to find our essential identity as the spirit and not the body and mind through which it makes it appearance.

(3) ‘The importance of developing Interfaith ideals’ – The central message of religious pluralism of the Hindus is crucial ingredient that can make religions once again the cohesive force in our society.

The teachings of Hinduism suggest that all disciplined human endeavours including science will eventually lead to conclusions that are in line with the findings of spirituality. This seems to be coming true in the Science of today.

By Jay Lakhani, Education Director, Hindu Council UK